Which Is Better Jigsaw Or Reciprocating Saw

Possible malfunctions

Like any other equipment, a reciprocating saw, due to various reasons, can fail during operation. Let’s consider the most typical malfunctions and Possible solutions.

Mechanical breakdowns

The locking device does NOT secure the web securely. The retainer is most likely worn out. In this case, replace the worn out part. However, in some cases, the prerequisite may be a discrepancy between the size of the holder and the blade, in this case you just need to replace the pollen.

Poor cutting quality and strong vibration. Most often, these symptoms occur when the brass guide bushings are worn. The only way to repair them is to replace the failed parts.

During operation, extraneous noise is heard and an increase in vibration is observed. Such problems can be the result of bearing failure. In most cases, the prerequisite is insufficient lubrication and high loads. You can restore tool performance by replacing bearings and ensuring effective lubrication.

Angle Grinder

The use of an angle grinder allows you to achieve:

High productivity;
High-quality cutting of hard and extra hard materials;
Significant cost savings, since abrasive discs are much cheaper than saber blades.

Use as an alternative to a reciprocating electric shovel is advisable when working with wood, as cutting wood with an angle grinder can cause serious injury. In addition, the reciprocating saw has the following advantages:

Replacing the cutting blade does not take much time;
The cut quality is quite acceptable;
Various types of saber blades provide the ability to work with any material.

Based on the above, we can say:

The angle grinder has a noticeable advantage when working with hard and especially hard materials. On the other hand, reciprocating saws work efficiently with wood and are safer in use.

Can a reciprocating saw replace circular saw, angle grinder, electric jigsaw

In this section of our review, it should be noted, first of all, that any universal tool is inferior specifically when performing a single work. Despite this, universal reciprocating saws are most widely used due to the ability to perform a large number of operations. Let’s consider in more detail the possibility of an alternative use of a reciprocating saw.

Criterias of choice

Since the Electric chewer is quite an expensive tool, choosing the right model is of great importance. This section will outline the main criteria to be considered when choosing a reciprocating saw.

Which Is Better Jigsaw Or Reciprocating Saw

First of all, one should clearly present the scope and specifics of the work that will be performed most often. The main criteria to pay special attention to are:

Estimated work intensity. Depending on the frequency of use and the duration of work, you should choose one of three modifications:

Household;
“Hobby”;
Professional.

Household models do not have high performance and are NOT designed for heavy loads. The power of such a tool ranges from 350 to 600 W, and the cost is quite affordable for a wide range of consumers.

Hobby models are designed for more intensive work. They are often used for work in the garden or in the country. The power of models of this class is from 600 to 1000 W, and the price can vary significantly depending on the manufacturer and the functionality of the instrument.

Professional saber hacksaws with a power of 1000 to 1500 W can work for a long time without interruption at maximum load. The cost of a professional “saber” is significantly higher than in the two previous modifications, therefore the use of such a tool in everyday life and on a personal plot is most often NOT advisable.

Power. The performance of the tool depends on this parameter, however, with an increase in this parameter, the weight and overall dimensions, as well as its price, inevitably increase. As statistics show, the most versatile are the Electric Hook, the power of which ranges from 0.8 to 1.1 kW.

The presence of a speed control mechanism allows you to select the optimal speed of movement of the web, depending on the material being processed. There are two ways to adjust:

Directly using the start button, while the speed of the reciprocating movement of the saw smoothly increases when pressed;

By means of sliders or a wheel that can be set to a certain position. Further adjustment is carried out by pressing the start button, while the maximum speed of the web will not exceed the speed limit even with the start button fully pressed.

The possibility of a pendulum motion allows to significantly increase the cutting speed and reduce the heating of the blade, which has a positive effect on its service life. This effect is achieved due to the fact that during the reverse movement, the saber slightly deviates from the direction of the cut, thus simplifying the removal of chips.

Possibility of using a support shoe. When equipped with this feature, the electric shooter can significantly increase the accuracy and quality of the cut, and reduce operator fatigue. This is due to the fact that the support shoe stabilizes the blade along the cutting plane.

Method for replacing the cutting blade. Suitable saw blades are used for working with different materials. Ease and speed of blade replacement affects not only productivity, but also increases the comfort of work.

The presence of a safety clutch makes it possible, in the event of a jam or kickback, to avoid damage to the tool and injury to the worker.

The possibility of soft start allows you to protect the power grid from possible overloads by starting currents and provides a gradual approach to the required speed.

An overload protection mechanism automatically disconnects the unit from the power supply in case of overheating or other critical situation.

The type of power supply is important when choosing an electric hob. Cordless saws are characterized by greater maneuverability and mobility, and in terms of their operational parameters, they are not much inferior to units operating from the mains. The disadvantages of this equipment include the high cost and limited operating time on one battery.

Having carefully analyzed the above criteria, you can safely proceed to the selection of the required model.

What is a reciprocating saw and what is it used for?

The reciprocating saw is a highly maneuverable, easy-to-use multifunctional cutting unit. In the process of processing, the cutting blade performs a reciprocating motion, the frequency and magnitude of the stroke of which depends on the specific working conditions. The working stroke of the blade in various samples can vary from 80 to 350 mm.

Depending on the power, the mass of a household or semi-professional electric saber electric shovel ranges from 2 to 5 kg, and in powerful professional samples up to 10 kg. Since the comfort of its use depends on the weight of the reciprocating saw, when choosing, it is necessary to clearly represent the scope and type of material with which to work.

Due to its maneuverability and the ability to process various types of materials, reciprocating saws are successfully used for:

Construction and renovation;
Manufacture of joinery;
Cutting pipes of various diameters;
Pruning trees, shrubs;
Harvesting firewood.

Depending on the power and gait of the working belt, and or another model can be used for a certain type of work. There are also universal modifications, but their cost is significantly higher than that of household and amateur samples.

The technical characteristics and possible field of application of various models of saber hacksaws will be discussed in more detail below, but here we note that the use of this tool can significantly reduce labor costs and increase work safety. In addition, the price range for this type of cutting tool allows you to choose the most suitable option for solving specific tasks.

Household tool

Enkor SPE-710 / 115E is a compact universal dust that can be effectively used for cutting various materials of small thickness. Metal body ensures reliability and long tool life.

Power consumption: 0.71 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 20 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 120/25
Weight: 2.6 kg

Availability of quick-release mount
Soft start capability
Double stroke frequency adjustment

Lack of speed control
There is a pendulum stroke

The estimated cost of a reciprocating saw is 3100 rubles.

SPETS BPS-800 is a medium-power household unit, effectively used when working in the garden and when cutting materials of small thickness. The scope of delivery includes a set of blades for processing various materials.

Power consumption: 0.8 kW
Maximum speed: 2500 rpm
Saw stroke: 21 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 65/8
Weight: 3.2 kg

Availability of quick-release mount
Soft start capability
Smooth speed control

There is a pendulum stroke

Estimated cost 3900 rubles.

PATRIOT RS 808 is one of the few saber dust that can be used for artistic contour cutting. The handle of the tool is rubberized, which significantly reduces vibration. The unit has a 6-mode speed controller.

Power consumption: 0.85 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 28 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 105/6
Weight: 2.7 kg

Quick release mount
Illumination of the working area
Speed control

There is a pendulum stroke
Lack of soft start

Estimated cost 4100 rubles.

The GRAPHITE 58G960 reciprocating saw is used for minor repair work related to cutting wood, metal, plastic and other materials of small thickness. Rugged aluminum alloy housing provides robustness and durability.

Power consumption: 0.35 kW
Maximum speed: 2500 rpm
Saw stroke: 17 mm
Limiting thickness of processed wood / metal: 60/6
Weight: 1.7 kg

Quick release mount
Lightweight and compact
Speed control

There is a pendulum stroke
Lack of soft start

Estimated cost 4800 rubles.

Einhell TH (TC).AP 650 E Most effective when working in the garden or in the country. The tool has a robust body that reliably protects the internal mechanisms from mechanical damage and an ergonomic rubberized handle that significantly reduces vibration levels.

Power consumption: 0.65 kW
Maximum speed: 3000 rpm
Saw stroke: 20 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 150/10
Weight: 2.8 kg

Quick release mount
Soft start capability
Speed control
Pendulum stroke

Lack of backlight
High price

The estimated cost of a reciprocating saw is 5000 rubles.

Industrial tool

Einhell TE-AP 1050 E is designed for working with brittle materials and fast cutting. The housing has special holes for cooling the electric motor.

Power consumption: 1.05 kW
Maximum speed: 2700 rpm
Saw stroke: 29 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 200/20
Weight: 3.8 kg

Quick release mount
Soft start capability
Speed control
Pendulum stroke

Lack of backlight
High price

Estimated cost 8200 rubles.

Makita JR3050T features traditional manufacturer’s reliability, high performance and long service life. The machine is equipped with a support shoe, 4 m mains cable and quick blade change mechanism.

Saw performance characteristics:

Power consumption: 1.01 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 28 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / pipe: 255/130
Weight: 3.2 kg

Quick release mount
Ergonomic rubberized handle
Speed control

No pendulum movement
Sun soft starters
High price

Estimated cost 9100 rubles.

AEG US 1300 XE. The reciprocating saw can be used for a wide variety of materials. In work it has established itself as a high-performance and reliable tool.

Power consumption: 1.3 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 30 mm
Limiting thickness of processed wood / metal: 20/250
Weight: 3.8 kg

Quick release mount
Ergonomic rubberized handle
Speed control

No pendulum movement
Sun soft starters
Lack of backlight
High price

The approximate price of a saber hacksaw is 10600 rubles.

Hitachi CR13V2 saw The most effective for dismantling, but can be successfully used in other industries. The tool is easy to operate and maintain.

Power consumption: 1.01 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 29 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / pipe: 300/19
Weight: 3.2 kg

Quick release mount
Ergonomic rubberized handle
Speed control

There is a pendulum stroke
Sun soft starters
High price

Estimated cost 12,000 rubles.

Makita JR 3060T is mainly used in construction and dismantling. The unit has a shock-resistant housing that provides maximum protection against mechanical damage and is distinguished by its reliability and long service life.

Power consumption: 1.25 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 32 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / pipe: 255/130
Weight: 4.2 kg

Quick release mount
Pendulum stroke capability
Speed control

Lack of backlight
Sun soft starters
High price

The approximate price of a reciprocating saw is 14,000 rubles.

Patriot RS 505. The tool was originally intended for cutting dry branches and twigs in the country, but in the process I came to the conclusion that the dust can be used for other purposes as well. I changed the canvas and tried to cut old water pipes, was pleasantly surprised with the result. In addition, the price of “sabelka” is quite affordable. Andrey, Kharkov.

Ryobi R18RS7. I must say right away that I am very pleased with the purchase. The blade is very easy to change, but the fastening is so reliable that it does not lead to the side when cutting the pollen. He worked with metal, wood, plastic and God knows what else, for two years no complaints. Expensive, however, but the instrument fully justified itself. Dmitry, Saratov.

Metabo SSE 18 LTX Compact 602266890. In principle, there are claims to the tool, but its cost is clearly overstated. I used different materials for cutting and was always pleased with the result, the main thing is to choose the right blade. Good all-round tool and no pulling required. Nikita, Nikolaev.

AEG BUS18BL. Great tool! The battery works great for 5-6 hours and charges quickly. To cut everything that comes to hand, I was convinced myself. At the dacha, pipes were cut and the floorboard was cut like a knife in butter. Very pleased with the purchase, I recommend it to everyone. Vasily, Smolensk.

Specialist BPS-800. Although the saw is domestic, it may well compete with the most famous brands! I have been working for her for two years in the harshest conditions and I have not had any complaints, and the acceptable price will completely shut the mouth of the damned capitalist! Sergey, Moscow region.

Professional tips for choosing a tool

First of all, you should clearly define the range of tasks to be performed and the operating conditions of the tool. It is NOT advisable to buy an expensive modification of a reciprocating saw for household needs, since its cost is unlikely to pay off.
For household needs and minor repairs, a 600 W unit is quite enough. For work in the garden and in the country, you can choose dust with a capacity of 800-1000 W, but for construction work and dismantling, you will need a tool with a power of 1 kW or more.
When choosing a model, its cost plays an important role. Equipment used exclusively for domestic purposes can cost from 3500 to 5500 rubles. An electric shovel for working in the garden and in the country can be purchased for 6000-8000 rubles, and to buy a powerful professional unit, you will need at least 8500 rubles.

Professional tips for choosing a tool

First of all, you should clearly define the range of tasks to be performed and the operating conditions of the tool. It is NOT advisable to buy an expensive modification of a reciprocating saw for household needs, since its cost is unlikely to pay off.
For household needs and minor repairs, a 600 W unit is quite enough. For work in the garden and in the country, you can choose dust with a capacity of 800-1000 W, but for construction work and dismantling, you will need a tool with a power of 1 kW or more.
When choosing a model, its cost plays an important role. Equipment used exclusively for domestic purposes can cost from 3500 to 5500 rubles. An electric shovel for working in the garden and in the country can be purchased for 6000-8000 rubles, and to buy a powerful professional unit, you will need at least 8500 rubles.

Angle Grinder

The use of an angle grinder allows you to achieve:

High productivity;
High-quality cutting of hard and extra hard materials;
Significant cost savings, since abrasive discs are much cheaper than saber blades.

Use as an alternative to a reciprocating electric shovel is advisable when working with wood, as cutting wood with an angle grinder can cause serious injury. In addition, the reciprocating saw has the following advantages:

Replacing the cutting blade does not take much time;
The cut quality is quite acceptable;
Various types of saber blades provide the ability to work with any material.

Based on the above, we can say:

The angle grinder has a noticeable advantage when working with hard and especially hard materials. On the other hand, reciprocating saws work efficiently with wood and are safer in use.

Criterias of choice

Since the Electric chewer is quite an expensive tool, choosing the right model is of great importance. This section will outline the main criteria to be considered when choosing a reciprocating saw.

First of all, one should clearly present the scope and specifics of the work that will be performed most often. The main criteria to pay special attention to are:

Estimated work intensity. Depending on the frequency of use and the duration of work, you should choose one of three modifications:

Household;
“Hobby”;
Professional.

Household models do not have high performance and are NOT designed for heavy loads. The power of such a tool ranges from 350 to 600 W, and the cost is quite affordable for a wide range of consumers.

The presence of a speed control mechanism allows you to select the optimal speed of movement of the web, depending on the material being processed. There are two ways to adjust:

Directly using the start button, while the speed of the reciprocating movement of the saw smoothly increases when pressed;

The possibility of a pendulum motion allows to significantly increase the cutting speed and reduce the heating of the blade, which has a positive effect on its service life. This effect is achieved due to the fact that during the reverse movement, the saber slightly deviates from the direction of the cut, thus simplifying the removal of chips.

The presence of a safety clutch makes it possible, in the event of a jam or kickback, to avoid damage to the tool and injury to the worker.

The possibility of soft start allows you to protect the power grid from possible overloads by starting currents and provides a gradual approach to the required speed.

An overload protection mechanism automatically disconnects the unit from the power supply in case of overheating or other critical situation.

Having carefully analyzed the above criteria, you can safely proceed to the selection of the required model.

Household tool

Enkor SPE-710 / 115E is a compact universal dust that can be effectively used for cutting various materials of small thickness. Metal body ensures reliability and long tool life.

Power consumption: 0.71 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 20 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 120/25
Weight: 2.6 kg

Availability of quick-release mount
Soft start capability
Double stroke frequency adjustment

Lack of speed control
There is a pendulum stroke

The estimated cost of a reciprocating saw is 3100 rubles.

Power consumption: 0.8 kW
Maximum speed: 2500 rpm
Saw stroke: 21 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 65/8
Weight: 3.2 kg

Availability of quick-release mount
Soft start capability
Smooth speed control

There is a pendulum stroke

Estimated cost 3900 rubles.

PATRIOT RS 808 is one of the few saber dust that can be used for artistic contour cutting. The handle of the tool is rubberized, which significantly reduces vibration. The unit has a 6-mode speed controller.

Power consumption: 0.85 kW
Maximum speed: 2800 rpm
Saw stroke: 28 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 105/6
Weight: 2.7 kg

Quick release mount
Illumination of the working area
Speed control

There is a pendulum stroke
Lack of soft start

Estimated cost 4100 rubles.

Power consumption: 0.35 kW
Maximum speed: 2500 rpm
Saw stroke: 17 mm
Limiting thickness of processed wood / metal: 60/6
Weight: 1.7 kg

Quick release mount
Lightweight and compact
Speed control

There is a pendulum stroke
Lack of soft start

Estimated cost 4800 rubles.

Power consumption: 0.65 kW
Maximum speed: 3000 rpm
Saw stroke: 20 mm
Maximum thickness of processed wood / metal: 150/10
Weight: 2.8 kg

Quick release mount
Soft start capability
Speed control
Pendulum stroke

Lack of backlight
High price

The estimated cost of a reciprocating saw is 5000 rubles.

Mechanical breakdowns

Poor cutting quality and strong vibration. Most often, these symptoms occur when the brass guide bushings are worn. The only way to repair them is to replace the failed parts.

Can a reciprocating saw replace circular saw, angle grinder, electric jigsaw

Possible malfunctions

Like any other equipment, a reciprocating saw, due to various reasons, can fail during operation. Let’s consider the most typical malfunctions and Possible solutions.

A circular saw

The benefits of a circular saw include:

Cut cleanliness;
Processing precision;
High performance.

In these parameters, the circular is noticeably superior to all existing models of hacksaws. On the other hand, the use of reciprocating saws provides:

Ability to work in hard-to-reach places;
Curved contour processing;
High maneuverability and mobility.

Based on this, the following conclusion can be drawn:

Replacing a circular saw with a saber saw is quite acceptable with low requirements for cut quality and work in hard-to-reach places. With increased requirements for cleanliness and quality of the cut, it is more advisable to use a circular saw.

Rating of the best household and professional reciprocating saws

disadvantages

Bosch GSA 10.8 V-LI

Reciprocating saw
Battery operation
Infinitely variable speed control
Weight 1.2 kg

From 8198 rub. In 17995 rubles.

Reviews on Makita JR3070CT. Comment

Bought for 15,700 08/12/2015 Assembly China.
For cutting foam blocks (dismantling partitions, replacing heating batteries, interior doors, cutting reinforcement when passing through a wall (cross)
Saw without spark, cuts everything, quickly and confidently!
The most important thing is to buy a saber blade for each job and choose an operating mode (speed)
I bought a canvas for aerated concrete (1900), but it is only suitable mainly for dismantling, if a more accurate cut is needed, then this is another skeletal type canvas with a stiffener.
Decent apparatus, very much helps in work when other tools are not strong!
The verdict in the category of Saber dust is the Best! (Mains 220 volts)

Comment

I took it for 7500 rubles in boxing. I do not regret it, it is a VERY useful thing in the household, no wires are needed now. I advise you to take at least 4 batteries for serious work (or use old ones from the second Bosch tool kits). Well, for work on small things, at least 2 batteries will have to be taken.
Disadvantages, if you look at it, are insignificant, since a saber saw is NOT designed for such serious materials as wide and thick boards, it is easier and faster to take a circular saw and cut it, but for example pipes, bars, thin boards (no more than 25 mm), corners, fittings, hairpins and branches she saw perfectly # 128578; For example, I sawed a pin M8 in 10 seconds. PE pipes generally keep quiet # 128578; Well, the round branches take current so, although the batteries have to be changed.
This saw is NOT suitable for wide and thick boards, choose a Bosch 65 CE circular saw (with motor overheat protection).

Advantages

Reliability
power
Vibration suppression system AVT
Includes: case and 3 different saws
pendulum stroke
Blowing the working area

Advantages

I advise everyone to take the L-BoX version, otherwise all the advantages of the saw will disappear.
1. Maneuverable, fits comfortably in the hand;
2. All 10.8 batteries are interchangeable from different Bosch tools;
3.2 batteries included;
4.2 nail files 100 mm included;
5. Very comfortable box;
6. Very powerful, nirazu NOT wedged;
7. Cut pipes, studs, bars (50 × 50), rails (25 × 50) very quickly and efficiently;
8. Safe operation (when compared with an angle grinder).

Advantages

Compact, convenient body

disadvantages

Differences in work and features

Jigsaw to cut material by the reciprocating motion of the saw, which should be selected according to the work ahead. Some types of tools allow you to adjust the vibrations back and forth in order to achieve less overheating of the cutting blade and get a smoother cut. The jigsaw allows you to spray both vertically and at an angle, and the thickness of the material, which can be sprayed, directly depends on the length of the saw.

The circular saw cuts with a toothed blade. It is necessary to hold this tool with two hands, unlike the previous one. Most manufacturers of circular saws anticipate the possibility of installing the tool with the disk upwards, thereby turning it into a small machine. The cut can be made both perpendicular to the plane of the material, and at various angles. The cutting depth is adjusted by moving the position of the saw platform and usually does NOT exceed 85 millimeters.

Before purchasing one of THESE tools, it will NOT be superfluous to familiarize yourself with their most significant advantages and disadvantages.

What to choose: jigsaw or circular saw?

The volume and nature of the upcoming work will help to determine the choice of the preferred option. For example, if you are a novice carpenter or the volume of work does NOT involve much effort and a long time, then it will be enough to purchase a jigsaw. It copes easily with spraying Not only chipboard and plywood, but also can be used for sawing small boards.

For more voluminous work, when it is supposed to be dusty for a long time and in large volumes, it is better to choose a circular saw. It can be used to spray sheet wood material, fairly thick boards and blocks.

The advantages of a jigsaw

Small and lightweight for one-handed use
Quick file change
The ability to make cuts from any area of the material, pre-drilling a hole
The ability to cut out various shapes

Advantages of the circular saw

Long disk life
Ideal for material handling where long slits or cross sections are required
Ability to carry out large volumes of work without having to stop to cool down
Significant increase in productivity due to the ability to mount the saw blade upward

Jigsaw or circular saw. What to choose?

When choosing a tool, which will be used on the farm for cutting various materials and will replace the usual hacksaw, you often have to choose one thing between a circular saw and a jigsaw. To determine which tool is best for you, you need to understand what are the Fundamental differences between These two devices.

disadvantages

Overheating of the saw leads to a significant deterioration in cut quality and the appearance of a slight waviness of the cut
Can’t set cutting depth
Pollen wear quickly

disadvantages

Cannot make a contoured cut or start a cut from the middle of sheet material
Massiveness
Debt saw blade replacement

Is it possible to replace one tool with a second

Although these tools can in some cases replace each other without noticeable difference in the quality of work and usability, the jigsaw is still a more versatile device. A saw, on the other hand, can do much more repetitive work. Although in many respects the circular saw has long overtaken even the most modern jigsaws, it is sometimes quite laborious to use it, and frequent replacement of the blade when working with various materials will NOT add convenience. You can replace pollen in a jigsaw in just a couple of minutes.

Having decided more precisely which type of instrument you need, you can start market research. You should NOT buy the cheapest option: such a tool will be much more noisy and, most likely, will heat up, which will negatively affect its service life. Conversely, it is not at all necessary to buy a tool for your needs with a whole set of different bells and whistles and capabilities, most of which you will definitely not need in your household. The best option would be to opt for a medium-price instrument, which will contain a set of the most necessary functions and will NOT hit your budget.

Sources:

http://masterok-remonta.ru/instrumenty/sabelnaya-pila.html
http://best-top-10.ru/luchshie-sabelnye-pily-rejting-foto-harakteristiki-tseny-otzyvy.html
http://pro-instrument.com/ruchnoj/lobzik-ili-tsirkulyarnaya-pila.html

Electric Saws better, jigsaw, reciprocating, which