Which Is Better Makita Or Metabo
Product comparison. Comparison of different Makita and Metabo tools
Comparison of different Makita and Metabo tools
Tools for professional work must be designed for heavy loads and for a longer time, these are tools for household use. That is why the products of companies such as Metabo and Makita are invented in such a way that they can easily withstand volumetric mechanical loads, moreover, during extremely long working hours.
Most assemblies are made of solid or reinforced components. These qualities distinguish these tools from tools for small household work. The history of Metabo goes back to 1914. Throughout its long existence, the company has been constantly developing and looking for possible options for improving its products.
The main specialization of the company is the development and manufacture of electric drills, impact drills, cordless drills and screwdrivers, rotary hammers, hand-held circular saws, jigsaws, milling cutters, staples, etc.
Let’s take a closer look at some of the Metabo tools. Metabo is famous for its electric drill models. Screwdrivers to almost the whole world. These self-powered devices combine power, fast battery recharge and ease of use. These qualities will be appreciated by both professional operators and amateur masters. The power of the bulk of stand-alone power tools directly depends on the current strength. Recently, the advantage in use has remained with 12V batteries, although there are more powerful 14V ones, since the 12s combine light weight, autonomy, power and convenience in the best way. These batteries are charged within an hour, which is a good quality that allows you to work without interruptions. If you want to choose an electric drill to your liking, then the first step is to pay attention to such a factor as the placement and shape of the handle. For example, if the handle is located in the center of gravity of the tool itself, this will reduce the load and increase the accuracy of the work. You can take the option with two handles if that’s more convenient for you. Certain models have an advantage over others if they have a punch function, which will significantly expand their scope of application. Models popular in recent years include such electric drills as BS 14.4 Li 1.3 Ahx2, SBP 12 Plus, BZ 9.6 SP, BE 250 RL and BZ 12 SP 2.0 Ah.
As for Makita, it is practically the same age as Metabo. Makita was founded back in 1915. By this time, the company had expanded significantly and turned into a huge corporation. The main direction in the production of this company belongs to the production and sale of stationary woodworking machines, power tools, household and garden tools and even construction vacuum cleaners. Makita is one of the leading manufacturers of power tools in the world. The tools of this company enjoy a well-deserved reputation among consumers working with wood, concrete and various building materials. The company extends an official 1 year warranty for all its products. Almost all elements of the products are made with increased strength, which guarantees them durability and reliability. Popular saw models from this manufacturer include LS1040, UC4020A, 5604R, LS1013 and more. Let’s take a deeper look at the Makita 5704 RK, for example. The model emits little noise and at the same time has a power of 1200 watts. The device is equipped with a solid base plate, a reliable riving knife. Double protective insulation, very strong cord. Pay attention to the slope for strength, safety and durability. 4900 rpm is a good indicator. The device weighs 3.6 kg.
Makita power drills are very popular. The main indicator, which is first paid attention to, is lower prices in comparison with analogues, while the tool remains reliable and technically advanced technology. Makita electric drills use a housing, bearings and gearbox that have been manufactured using the finest materials. Drills perform excellently in conditions close to extreme. Thanks to their good balance, they are comfortable to hold. Crafted with intelligence, the drills will appeal to both hobbyists and professional operators. The tools of this company can be found almost everywhere. In the house, at a construction site or in enterprises.
Hammer drills from Makita also occupy an important position in the global construction market. All models of rock drills, being lightweight, are capable of showing high impact energy. Makita hammer drills are also capable of making holes in extremely hard working materials, in reinforced concrete, for example, or in stone. It can also be used like a conventional drill. Namely, if you have to work with heavy-duty materials, you will find that Makita tools move forward quickly and easily. Each hammer drill model has a very convenient mode switch that turns your drilling into hammer drilling, screwdriving or chiselling. Almost all models of rotary hammer drills have a handle with a soft rubberized pad, this guarantees total control over your working tool and does not allow the palm to slip. Conclusion: if you want to find a hammer drill for intensive work, then the Makita hammer drill is sure to be the right choice.
Which is better: Bosch or Makita?
In any environment, professionals often get into arguments about which brand is better. For graphs, this is, of course, the eternal confrontation between Nikon and Canon, for smartphone owners. Apple with its iOS and Samsung with Android, etc.
Builders and finishers also do not stand aside, and quite often they discuss the advantages and disadvantages of certain brands of tools. But if you compare. Then compare the best representatives, so we turn to the results of the survey on the site. As of May 2017, in a survey of their preferred brand of construction tools, 31% of users voted for Makita and 23% for Bosch. So we will choose the leader from these two brands and try to decide which is better. Bosch or Makita.
Bosch (or rather, Robert Bosch GmbH) is a group of German companies that specializes in the production of high-tech equipment in various fields. The company was founded in 1886 and initially focused on electrical engineering and precision mechanics. It is not surprising that starting in the 1890s (the start of electrification in Germany), Bosch’s business began to develop rapidly, occupying new market niches, including those related to the design and production of power tools.
The presence of its own engineering department in the company has served well in the expansion in the market of household and professional tools. It was under the Bosch brand that such devices as a jigsaw, a rotary hammer, a variable grinder, a cordless rotary hammer, etc. Were first released. This also includes the SDS-Plus perforating drill attachment system. It was developed and first introduced by German engineers.
In general, Bosch power tools fully comply with our ideas about German quality standards. They are reliable and durable, so the purchase should be considered as a fairly long-term investment.
Makita Corporation (Japan) was founded a little later. In 1915, and initially focused on the manufacture of generators and electric motors. In 1958, the first line for the production of power tools was launched: the first electric planer was released under the Makita brand, which at that time had no analogues.
Today the company produces more than 1000 brands of tools of 350 different types. Technological capacities are partially moved outside Japan and are located in Great Britain, Romania and Germany.
Comparison by key parameters
Professional and household lines
For a correct comparison between Bosch and Makita, it is worthwhile to figure out which lines of tools these corporations produce.
- “Blue Series”. Professional equipment. Actually, this is the very Bosch, which is characterized by high power, long service life and safety margin.
- “Green Series” is a power tool for household use. Due to limitations in power and functionality, as well as the use of less durable materials, the manufacturer seriously reduces the cost of products. But their safety margin also suffers. At least in comparison with the professional line.
Sometimes in the “green series” models are released, which are then planned to be brought to the professional market. Therefore, the household segment often serves as a testing ground for new products.
- It produces only professional tools under its own brand, so it should be compared only with the “blue series” of Bosch. The performance parameters of the products are at the highest level, so that there are almost no significant claims from the craftsmen.
- In the 90s, Makita Corporation attempted to launch a line of household power tools under the Maktec brand. The products turned out to be cheaper, but they were significantly inferior to their professional counterparts in terms of power and reliability.
Cost and other factors
- Power. In principle, it is equivalent for both brands (at the same level of energy consumption). In rare cases, Bosch outperforms the Makita in certain parameters (for example, efficiency on concrete).
- Ergonomics. Here Makita is in a better position primarily because of the lighter weight of the tools. With long-term work, this plus becomes quite significant.
- Resource. Bosch with its German quality is noticeably better. Despite the fact that Makita has good control over production in different countries, the overall level of reliability of the tools is still somewhat lower.
- Functionality. This parameter can be assessed in two ways: Bosch is the first to introduce new functions, while Makita is perfect for “bringing them to mind”. But with a significant time delay.
- Prices. Bosch costs a little more on average (if we talk about tools of a comparable class). On the other hand, the difference is usually not so significant, and it can be compensated by finding a retail outlet with a more democratic pricing policy.
Instead of a conclusion
It will probably not be possible to answer unequivocally the question “Which is better. Bosch or Makita”: both brands produce sufficiently high-quality, reliable and functional tools, which rightfully occupy leading positions in this market segment. So, choosing between Bosch and Makita, we choose not between good and bad, but between good. And also good, but slightly different.
Makita Brand Features:
Japan. The assembly is usually Chinese;
Affordable prices (compared to Bosch).
As you can see, the difference between brands in their approach. For Bosch, this is German precision, reliability and power. Makita is characterized by convenience, economy in terms of price and excellent equipment. In other words, the former are guided by the tool itself, and the latter by whoever will use it. That allows you to give a clear answer to who is better. Namely:
If a tool is needed for a beginner and not for frequent use, then Makita should be chosen.
While professional builders are better off choosing Bosch, the 3 year warranty and reliability are more important when using power tools permanently.
Categories hunted by masters
In fact, in order to get a positive rating, a tool must have only a few categories:
- Affordable price;
- High resource;
According to the first indicator, Makita wins unambiguously. With regard to the resource, everything is not so simple. The fact is that Bosch has two lines of tools. Household and professional (yellow and blue).
Makita has an exceptionally professional line of tools. But let’s not forget that back in the early 90s Makita created a subsidiary company Maktec.
It is she who sells household tools. It turns out that manufacturers are equal in this category.
As any professional repairer will tell you, most Bosch equipment is more complex in design. But it also provides a little more functionality. In comparison, the Makita is simpler. However, this simplicity provides a huge resource. The tool simply does not break.
The tool, of a relatively low price category, is intended for professionals, has two nickel-cadmium batteries, an additional flashlight. The design of the tool protects it from impacts in case of falling, the set includes a keyless chuck. The screwdriver has a function of stepless setting of revolutions, the maximum number of revolutions is 1100 per minute, which allows working comfortably. The tool is provided with 22 steps of torque, the set includes a charger.
Features of the Bosch brand:
Germany. The assembly is usually Malaysian;
Basically three years warranty (one year in Makits);
Better performance characteristics and, as a consequence, more weight.
BOSCH GSR 10.8-2-LI
The professional tool is very compact, has a charge indicator with LEDs, and is equipped with all the necessary functions and additional settings. The maximum number of revolutions is 1200 per minute. The screwdriver has a battery that can work four times longer than previous models, and has 25 torque steps. One of the functions of the instrument, protection of the battery against overheating and full discharge, has an LED backlight. The screwdriver cable can be connected to the USB port, the tool handle is equipped with a shock-absorbing gasket, the kit includes a keyless chuck.